Good evening Ladies and Gentlemen:
Here are the following closes for gold and silver today:
Gold: $1220.10 up $1.10 (comex closing time)
Silver: $16.78 up 3 cents (comex closing time)
In the access market 5:15 pm
Gold $1221.50
silver $16.86
Gold/silver trading: see kitco charts on right side of the commentary.
Today good news came that there is a ceasefire in Eastern Ukraine and also it seems that Germany has blinked with respect to Greece. However late in the day, the Eurocrats threw cold water that they are close to a deal. This deal still has a long way to go and we will know for sure on Monday.
Following is a brief outline on gold and silver comex figures for today:
The gold comex today had a poor delivery day, registering 1 notice served for 100 oz. Silver comex registered 3 notices for 15,000 oz .
Three months ago the comex had 303 tonnes of total gold. Today the total inventory rests at 256.01 tonnes for a loss of 47 tonnes over that period.
In silver, the open interest rose again by 1188 contracts despite Tuesday’s silver price being down by 11 cents. The total silver OI continues to remain relatively high with today’s reading at 169,334 contracts. The bankers are not happy campers tonight with respect to the high OI in silver.
We had 3 notices filed for 15,000 oz
In gold we had another surprisingly fall in OI as gold was down $12.60 yesterday. The total comex gold OI rests tonight at 389,685 for a loss of 3,547 contracts. Today we had 1 notices served upon for 100 oz. We are also coming pretty close to rock bottom OI gold support being around 359,000.
Today, we had a withdrawal of 1.8 tonnes of gold inventory at the GLD/Inventory at 771.51 tonnes
In silver, /SLV no change in of silver inventory to the SLV/Inventory 320.327
We have a few important stories to bring to your attention today…
Let’s head immediately to see the major data points for today
.
First: GOFO rates: the crooks are no longer reporting.
Let us now head over to the comex and assess trading over there today.
Here are today’s comex results:
The total gold comex open interest fell by another 3,547 contracts today from 393,232 down to 389,685 as gold was down by $12.60 yesterday (at the comex close). We are now in the big delivery month of the active February contract and here the OI fell by 2 contracts from 658 down to 656. We had 0 contracts served upon yesterday. Thus we lost 2 contracts or an additional 200 oz will not stand for delivery for the February contract. The next contract month of March saw it’s OI rise by 3 contracts up to 1269. The next big active delivery month is April and here the OI fell by 3,408 contracts down to 264,072. The estimated volume today (which is just comex sales during regular business hours of 8:20 until 1:30 pm est) was 71,053. The confirmed volume yesterday ( which includes the volume during regular business hours + access market sales the previous day) was awful at 125,445 contracts even with much help from the HFT boys. Today we had 1 notices filed for 100 oz.
And now for the wild silver comex results. Silver OI surprisingly rose by 1188 contracts from 168,146 up to 169,334 despite the fact that silver was down by 11 cents yesterday. The bankers were not able to shake any silver leaves from the silver tree and thus the reason for continuous raids by the bankers. I guess the CME needs to resort to another silver margin hike as this would be the only way to shake some longs to depart. We are now in the non active contract month of February and here the OI rose by 3 contracts rising to 23. We had 0 notices filed yesterday so we gained 3 silver contracts or an additional 15,000 oz of silver will stand for delivery in this February contract month. The next big active contract month is March and here the OI fell by only 2,944 contracts down to 78,750. First day notice for the gold and silver February contract months is on Friday, Feb 27.2015 or two weeks away. The estimated volume today was awful at 21,526 contracts (just comex sales during regular business hours). The confirmed volume yesterday was excellent (regular plus access market) at 55,366 contracts. We had 3 notices filed for 15,000 oz today.
February initial standings
Feb 12.2015
Gold |
Ounces |
Withdrawals from Dealers Inventory in oz | nil oz |
Withdrawals from Customer Inventory in oz | nil |
Deposits to the Dealer Inventory in oz | nil |
Deposits to the Customer Inventory, in oz | 40,126.87 oz (HSBC) |
No of oz served (contracts) today | 1 contracts (100 oz) |
No of oz to be served (notices) | 655 contracts (65,500 oz) |
Total monthly oz gold served (contracts) so far this month | 550 contracts(55,000 oz) |
Total accumulative withdrawals of gold from the Dealers inventory this month | |
Total accumulative withdrawal of gold from the Customer inventory this month |
148,004.0 oz |
Today, we had 0 dealer transactions
we had 0 dealer withdrawals:
total dealer withdrawal: nil oz
we had 0 dealer deposit:
total dealer deposit: nil oz
we had 0 customer withdrawals
total customer withdrawal: nil oz
we had 1 customer deposits:
i) Into HSBC: 40,126.87 oz (and this arrived from a withdrawal at Scotia customer yesterday)
total customer deposits; 40,126.87 oz
We had 1 adjustment
i) from the HSBC vaults: 96.45 oz (3 kilobars) leave the customer account and this landed into the dealer account of HSBC
Today, 0 notices was issued from JPMorgan dealer account and 0 notices were issued from their client or customer account. The total of all issuance by all participants equates to 1 contract of which 0 notices were stopped (received) by JPMorgan dealer and 1 notices were stopped (received) by JPMorgan customer account.
To calculate the total number of gold ounces standing for the December contract month, we take the total number of notices filed for the month (550) x 100 oz or 55,000 oz , to which we add the difference between the OI for the front month of February (656 contracts) minus the number of notices served today x 100 oz (1 contracts) x 100 oz = 120,500 oz, the amount of gold oz standing for the February contract month.( 3.748 tonnes)
Thus the initial standings:
550 (notices filed for the month x( 100 oz) or 55,000 oz + { 656 (OI for the front month of Feb)- 1 (number of notices served upon today) x 100 oz per contract} = 120,500 oz total number of ounces standing for the February contract month. (3.748 tonnes)
we lost 2 contracts or 200 oz will not stand in this February contract month.
Total dealer inventory: 804,950.959 oz or 25.03 tonnes
Total gold inventory (dealer and customer) = 8.231 million oz. (256.01) tonnes)
Several weeks ago we had total gold inventory of 303 tonnes, so during this short time period 47 tonnes have been net transferred out. However I believe that the gold that enters the gold comex is not real. I cannot see continual additions of strictly kilobars.
end
And now for silver
February silver: initial standings
feb 12 2015:
Silver |
Ounces |
Withdrawals from Dealers Inventory | nil oz |
Withdrawals from Customer Inventory | 643,602.37 oz (Brinks, HSBC,Scotia) |
Deposits to the Dealer Inventory | nil |
Deposits to the Customer Inventory | nil |
No of oz served (contracts) | 3 contracts (15,000 oz) |
No of oz to be served (notices) | 20 contracts (100,000 oz) |
Total monthly oz silver served (contracts) | 384 contracts (1,920,000 oz) |
Total accumulative withdrawal of silver from the Dealers inventory this month | |
Total accumulative withdrawal of silver from the Customer inventory this month | 3,258,058.4 oz |
Today, we had 0 deposit into the dealer account:
total dealer deposit: nil oz
we had 0 dealer withdrawal:
total dealer withdrawal: nil oz
We had 0 customer deposits:
total customer deposit: nil oz
We had 3 customer withdrawals:
i) Out of Brinks: 3086.900 oz
ii) Out of HSBC: 600,026.09 oz
iii) Out of Scotia: 40,489.38 oz
total customer withdrawal: 643,602.37 oz
we had 0 adjustments
Total dealer inventory: 67.864 million oz
Total of all silver inventory (dealer and customer) 175.564 million oz
.
The total number of notices filed today is represented by 3 contracts for 15,000 oz. To calculate the number of silver ounces that will stand for delivery in February, we take the total number of notices filed for the month (384) x 5,000 oz = 1,920,000 oz to which we add the difference between the OI for the front month of February (23)- the number of notices served upon today (3) x 5,000 oz per contract = 2,020,000 oz, the number of silver oz standing for the February contract month
Initial standings for silver for the February contract month:
384 contracts x 5000 oz= 1,920,000 oz + (23) OI for the front month – (3) number of notices served upon x 5000 oz per contract = 2,020,000 oz, the number of silver ounces standing.
we gained 3 contracts or an additional 15,000 oz will stand in this month of February.
for those wishing to see the rest of data today see:
http://www.harveyorgan.wordpress.com or http://www.harveyorganblog.com
end
The two ETF’s that I follow are the GLD and SLV. You must be very careful in trading these vehicles as these funds do not have any beneficial gold or silver behind them. They probably have only paper claims and when the dust settles, on a collapse, there will be countless class action lawsuits trying to recover your lost investment.
There is now evidence that the GLD and SLV are paper settling on the comex.
***I do not think that the GLD will head to zero as we still have some GLD shareholders who think that gold is the right vehicle to be in even though they do not understand the difference between paper gold and physical gold. I can visualize demand coming to the buyers side:
i) demand from paper gold shareholders
ii) demand from the bankers who then redeem for gold to send this gold onto China
vs no sellers of GLD paper.
And now the Gold inventory at the GLD:
Feb 12: we had a withdrawal of 1.8 tonnes of gold from the GLD/Inventory 771.51 tonnes
Feb 11.no change in gold inventory at the GLD/Inventory 773.31 tonnes
Feb 10 no change in gold inventory at the GLD/inventory 773.31 tonnes
Feb 9 no change in gold inventory at the GLD/Inventory 773.31 tonnes
feb 6/ no change in gold inventory tonight/inventory 773.31 tonnes
feb 5. we had another addition of 5.38 tonnes of gold to the GLD/Inventory tonight at 773.31 tonnes
Feb 4/2015; we had another addition of 2.99 tonnes added to the GLD inventory/Inventory tonight 767.93
Feb 3.2015: today a withdrawal of 1.79 tonnes of gold inventory removed from the GLD/Inventory at 764.94
feb 2/ a huge addition of 8.36 tonnes of “paper” gold inventory/Inventory tonight at 766.73 tonnes
jan 30. we had no change in gold inventory/Inventory at 758/37 tonnes
Jan 29/we had an addition of 5.67 tonnes of gold inventory at the GLD/Inventory at 758.37 tonnes
Jan 28/no changes in gold inventory at the GLD/Inventory at 952.44 tonnes
Jan 27.we had a monstrous “paper” addition of 9.26 tonnes of gold into the GLD tonight/Inventory at 952.44 tonnes
Feb 12/2015 /we had a withdrawal of 1.8 tonnes of gold inventory at the GLD/
inventory: 771.51 tonnes.
The registered vaults at the GLD will eventually become a crime scene as real physical gold departs for eastern shores leaving behind paper obligations to the remaining shareholders. There is no doubt in my mind that GLD has nowhere near the gold that say they have and this will eventually lead to the default at the LBMA and then onto the comex in a heartbeat (same banks).
GLD : 771.51 tonnes.
end
And now for silver (SLV):
Feb 12 no change in silver inventory at the SLV/inventory at 320.327 million oz
Feb 11 no change in silver inventory at the SLV/inventory at 320.327 million oz
Feb 10 no change in silver inventory at the SLV/inventory at 320.327 million oz
Feb 9 no change in silver inventory/SLV inventory at 320.327 million oz
Feb 6 no change in silver inventory/SLV’s silver inventory at 320.327 million oz.
Feb 5.we had no change in silver inventory/320.327 million oz/
Feb 4/we had a small withdrawal of 136,000 oz of silver from the SLV vaults/Inventory/320.327 million oz
feb 3.2015: we had a good addition of 1.149 million oz of silver inventory/inventory 320.463 million oz
Feb 2 no change in silver inventory at the SLV/inventory at 319.314
million oz.
jan 30 no change in silver inventory at the SLV/inventory at 319.314
million oz
Jan 29/no change in silver inventory/SLV inventory at 319.314 million oz
Jan 28/no changes in silver inventory/SLV inventory at 319.314 million oz
Jan 27/no change in silver inventory/SLV inventory at 319.314 million oz
feb 12/2015 we had no change in silver inventory/
SLV inventory registers: 320.327 million oz
end
And now for our premiums to NAV for the funds I follow:
Note: Sprott silver fund now for the first time into the negative to NAV
Sprott and Central Fund of Canada.
(both of these funds have 100% physical metal behind them and unencumbered and I can vouch for that)
1. Central Fund of Canada: traded at Negative 6.1% percent to NAV in usa funds and Negative 5.7 % to NAV for Cdn funds!!!!!!!
Percentage of fund in gold 61.2%
Percentage of fund in silver:38.4%
cash .4%
( feb12/2015)
2. Sprott silver fund (PSLV): Premium to NAV rises to + 3.06%!!!!! NAV (Feb 12/2015)
3. Sprott gold fund (PHYS): premium to NAV falls to +.06% to NAV(feb 12 /2015)
Note: Sprott silver trust back into positive territory at +3.06%.
Sprott physical gold trust is back into positive territory at +.06%
Central fund of Canada’s is still in jail.
end
And now for your most important physical stories on gold and silver today:
Early gold trading from Europe early Thursday morning:
(courtesy Mark O’Byrne)
Stalemate At Minsk Summit And Eurogroup Meeting Suggests Tensions In Europe And Globally Are Set To Escalate
– Diplomats best hopes for Minsk is for freeze in hostilities
– Russia engages the U.S. in war of words as tensions mount
– Greece and EU buy time – no agreement thus far
– Anti-austerity parties in Spain and Greece may bring down the euro
The Minsk Summit which was called at the urgent behest of Angela Merkel and Francois Hollande seems not to have yielded any tangible outcome despite the high stakes on all sides.
Media reports present little new information regarding the talks which ran through the night. The Guardian reports that President Putin confirmed a ceasefire agreement has been reached which would come into effect on Sunday.
Ukraine’s Poroshenko denied an agreement had reached, insisting that some of Russia’s demands were “unacceptable”.
While a ceasefire, if it does transpire, will bring much relief to the people of East Ukraine it is unlikely to last without a real political solution. The Pro-Russian rebels do not trust Poroshenko.
The Donetsk and Luhansk regions – which are inhabited predominantly by ethnic Russians – voted to secede from Ukraine following the overthrow of former, pro-Russian, Prime Minister Yanukovich last year.
As such, the rebels do not recognize Poroshenko as the leader of Ukraine and reject a return to the Ukrainian state in it’s current form. They are apparently willing to return as part of a federalized Ukraine which would limit the power of both Kiev and Moscow which seems reasonable.
However, for the moment, the most that can be hoped for is a “freezing” of hostilities according to the BBC.
But while Germany and France seek to calm the situation in Ukraine to avert it escalating into a proxy war on an already unstable Europe’s border, Russia and the U.S. seem intent on provoking each other. While Obama, on Tuesday evening, warned Putin that he must reverse course and cease arming the rebels, the head Russia’s Security Council made a counter-warning.
Bloomberg reported Nicolai Patrushev, one of Putin’s closest advisors as saying, “the current U.S. approach will lead to inevitable confrontation with Russia and China.”
The European de-facto leadership clearly view the resolution of the Ukraine crisis as of the utmost urgency. At the same time the U.S. are taking a very hawkish stance. If the U.S. where to begin arming Ukraine’s government it would lead to great tension with Europe.
At the same time Europe is at risk of imploding. Yesterday’s talks among finance ministers yielded nothing and the EU appears to be buying time saying they need to be continued on Monday. Greece appear to have succeeded in calling Europe’s bluff, at least for now, given that Wednesday had been announced as the dead-line for Greece to comply.
It would appear Europe fears a Greek exit from the euro more than they had suggested. In Today’s Telegraph, Ambrose Evans Pritchard has an interesting piece blaming the Northern European elites for the rise of left wing groups in Southern Europe.
In Spain the left-wing Podemos party are polling at 28%. The ruling conservative party only have the support of 21% of the population.
“Europe’s policy elites can rail angrily at the folly of these plans if they wish, but they must answer why ex-Trotskyists threatening to dismantle market capitalism are taking a major EMU state by storm. It is what happens when 5.46m people lack jobs, when 2m households still have no earned income, and when youth unemployment is still running at 51.4pc, and home prices are down 42pc, six years into a depression.”
In Italy he identifies a similar pattern,
“The revolt in Italy has different contours but is just as dangerous for Brussels. Italians may not wish to leave the euro but political consent for the project but broken down. All three opposition parties are now anti-euro in one way or another. Beppe Grillo’s Five Star movement – with 108 seats in parliament – is openly calling for a return to the lira.”
These are serious developments for the EU and whatever the result of Syriza’s brinkmanship the anti-austerity groups are likely to be bolstered by the defiance of the Greeks. What loyalty can the 51% of unemployed youth have to the European project?
More frighteningly for Europe, what reason have these European groups not to pivot toward Russia and the East. But Europe cannot afford to write down the debts of these countries so it is in a catch-22 situation.
Irish Finance Minister, Michael Noonan, is not willing – at this strategically expedient time – to put pressure on the EU to make similar concessions to Ireland should Greece achieve a write-down in it’s debt or some other favorable outcome.
The same cannot be said for Spain and Italy whose incumbent governments are facing massive pressure from their anti-austerity opponents domestically.
In the absence of a strong and united anti-austerity movement in Ireland it is likely that the government will continue with some slight justification to support the status quo despite crises in homelessness, health care and repossession of family homes.
Europe seems to be in disarray. A currency crisis may be imminent. Owners of physical gold will find it a safe harbour in the coming months and years.
For an in depth look at currency wars read: Currency Wars: Bye, Bye Petrodollar – Buy, Buy Gold
MARKET UPDATE
Today’s AM fix was USD 1,225.25, EUR 1,080.75 and GBP 803.13 per ounce.
Yesterday’s AM fix was USD 1,235.50, EUR 1,092.40 and GBP 807.73 per ounce.
Gold fell 1.16 percent or $14.30 and closed at $1,219.70 an ounce yesterday, while silver slipped 0.71 percent or $0.12 closing at $16.79 an ounce.
Gold inched up after its 1 percent loss overnight, after hitting a five week low in Asia. Demand for the yellow metal has been driven by safe haven bids from the eurozone ‘Grexit’ scenario and also from Chinese buying the dip ahead of Lunar New Year.
Near the end of day trading in Singapore spot gold was trading at $1,222.30 an ounce.
Yesterday, the U.S. dollar hit a three week high versus other major currencies. Eurozone finance ministers were not able to reach an agreement on Greece’s bail-out and austerity terms.
The next U.S. Federal Reserve meeting is scheduled for March 17-18, but until then the horizon for U.S. interest rate hikes looks likely for June. A rise in the interest rate could strengthen the U.S. dollar further and dampen the appeal for the yellow metal. Whether the hike is already being priced into the gold price or not, time will tell.
Gold in London fell to its lowest since January 9th at $1,216.45 an ounce, before recovering to trade up 0.4 percent at $1,223.78. Silver rose 1 percent to $16.92 an ounce. Platinum gained 1.1 percent at $1,203.85 an ounce, while palladium was up 0.9 percent at $772.75 an ounce.
The World Gold Council data released today noted that gold demand hit a five-year low last year as buying of jewellery, coins and bars failed to keep pace with 2013’s elevated levels, particularly in major consumer China.
The Bank of Japan deflated hopes of further monetary easing which gave gold a boost early in trading to hit $1,233.10. The Bank of England lowered its 2015 inflation rate target to 0.5 percent from 1.4 percent after what it sees as a temporary slump. While Sweden’s Central Bank, the Riksbank, slashed interest rates by 10 basis points in efforts to stop the nordic country’s spiralling deflation problem.
end
For your interest…
(courtesy Bloomberg/GATA)
India smugglers, and their bodies, take a break from gold
By Swansy Afonso
Bloomberg News
Wednesday, February 11, 2015
MUMBAI, India — In the two years since India took steps to pare gold imports, people used all sorts of tricks as the smuggling business boomed — from simply tucking the metal under a turban to jamming it up their rectums.
That illegal trade, though, is fading now.
Premiums have evaporated for black-market bullion valued at about $8 billion last year, industry data show. That’s because the government has begun easing import curbs that in 2013 knocked India from the top spot among gold buyers. In a country that accounts for a quarter of world demand, legal transactions are recovering, with annual purchases from overseas poised to jump 50 percent. …
… For the remainder of the report:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-02-11/india-smugglers-and-th…
end
You are already aware of this, but it is worth repeating:
(courtesy Bloomberg news/GATA)
Central banks are boosting their gold reserves
“The government doesn’t care about gold. … They don’t care about its price.” — Doug Casey, February 11, 2015.
* * *
By Eddie Van Der Walt and Nicholas Larkin
Bloomberg News
Thursday, February 12, 2015
LONDON — Central banks purchased enough gold in 2014 to buy 75 Boeing Co. Dreamliners.
Governments added 477.2 metric tons to their reserves, the second-biggest increase in 50 years and 17 percent more than a year earlier, the World Gold Council said in a report today. Based on the average price of gold in 2014, central banks probably paid about $19.4 billion. A Boeing 787-9 has a $257.1 million retail price, according to the company’s website.
Central banks have added to gold reserves for the past five years, a reversal from two decades of selling since the late 1980s. Purchases will be at least 400 tons this year, according to estimates from the London-based council, which represents 17 gold producers. Total demand for gold fell last year as Chinese consumers bought less jewelry, bars, and coins. …
… For the remainder of the report:
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-02-12/central-banks-hungry-f…
end
A great piece from Bill Holter
(courtesy Bill Holter/Miles Franklin)
PEACE! …and Greece
And now for the important paper stories for today:
Early Thursday morning trading from Europe/Asia
1. Stocks mainly higher on major Asian bourses / the yen falls to 119.76
1b Chinese yuan vs USA dollar/ yuan slightly weakens to 6.2454
2 Nikkei up 327.04 or 1.88%
3. Europe stocks all the green // USA dollar index down to 94.63/
3b Japan 10 year yield huge rise to .40%/ (Japan buying 100% of bond issuance)/Japanese yen vs usa cross now at 119.81/everybody watching the huge support levels of 117.20 and that level acting as a catapult for the markets.
3c Nikkei now above 17,000/
3e The USA/Yen rate still below the 120 barrier this morning/
3fOil: WTI 50.36 Brent: 56.07 /all eyes are focusing on oil prices. This should cause major defaults as derivatives blow up.
3g/ Gold up /yen down;
3h/ Japan is to buy the equivalent of 108 billion usa dollars worth of bonds per MONTH or $1.3 trillion
Japan’s GDP equals 5 trillion usa/thus bond purchases of 26% of GDP
3i Japan to buy 100% of all new Japanese debt and by 2018 they will have 25% of all Japanese debt. Fifty percent of Japanese budget financed with debt (see Von Greyerz)
3j Oil rises this morning for WTI and Brent
3k Sweden enters NIRP/lowers it’s interest rate by 10 basis points to -.10% (see below)
3l Greek 10 year bond yield :10.53% (down 7 basis points in yield)
3m Gold at $1223.00. dollars/ Silver: $16.85
3n USA vs Russian rouble: ( Russian rouble down 1 per dollar in value) 66.12!!!!!!
3 0 oil into the 50 dollar handle for WTI and 56 handle for Brent
3p ECB removes Greek sovereign collateral in their investment strategy (on Feb 11). This leaves only ELA funding for the next two weeks. Maximum allowed 60 billion euros for this funding. They also limit the amount of treasuries that Greek can issue. Greece rejects any more EU funds and thus rejects the European ultimatum to accept this funding!!
Meeting yesterday failed to decide Greece’s fate
3Q SNB (Swiss National Bank) still intervening again driving down the SF/window dressing/Swiss rumours of intervention to keep the soft peg at 1.05 Swiss Francs/euro and major support for the Euro.
3r the world still awaits the Greek decision today.
3s Merkel and Hollande in Belarus arranged to obtain a ceasefire in Eastern Ukraine/talks with Putin
4. USA 10 yr treasury bond at 2.04% early this morning. Thirty year rate well below 3% (2.62%!!!!)/yield curve flattens/foreshadowing recession
5. Details: Ransquawk, Bloomberg/Deutsche bank Jim Reid
(courtesy zero hedge)/your early morning trading from Asia and Europe)
Market Wrap: Whirlwind Manic-Depressive Session Sees Futures Slide Then Surge
So far it has been an overnight session which clearly forgot to take its Lexapro, with futures first tumbling after CNBC’s “leak” that a Greek deal had been reached was refuted, only to surge subsequently on both the Riskbank’s foray into NIRP and QE which crushed the Swedish currency and sent its stocks to recorder highs, and more importantly, on the latest ceasefire out of Minsk which has pushed Russian and European assets substantially higher. While only the most naive believe that any palpable end to Ukraine hostilities will emerge as a result of today’s delay, expect for Greek headlines to return with a vengeance as today it is Tsipras’ turn to speak at a summit of the 28 European Union leaders set to begin momentarily.
For now, however, the algos have been delighted to forget the latest Greek disappointment and focus on the utopia that central planners have in mind, if only for the 1%, and send US equity futures surging, and on pace to resume their grind higher to all time highs.
Looking at specific regions, Asian equity markets trade mixed after following suit from a lacklustre Wall Street close, which saw the S&P 500 finish relatively flat. The Nikkei 225 (+1.8%) outperformed bolstered by yesterday’s sharp fall in JPY which prompted the index to briefly break above the 18,000 level for the first time this year. Elsewhere, both the Hang Seng (+0.44%) and Shanghai Comp (-0.50%) fluctuated between gains and losses, with a rally in the telecoms sector helping overcome weakness across energy stocks, amid yesterday’s oil price slump.
The Eurogroup meeting on Greece failed to come to a meaningful conclusion last night and whilst this was expected amid ongoing tensions, the lack of cooperation between the two parties saw equity futures open lower this morning. However this trend reversed at the open of the cash markets, with stock specific news, such as positive earnings from the likes of Renault (+9.4%) and Credit Suisse (+9.6%), pushing European indices higher.
Sentiment was further bolstered through the morning after a technical break in the DAX future, where a spike took out stops out through the high before the EUREX close yesterday (10800) and the high on Tuesday’s session (10816). The move higher also prompted rumours of a deal being brokered between Greece and the Eurogroup, however these reports were not based on any information of substance. Another contributing factor has been Russia’s President Putin stated that a cease-fire has been agreed with Ukraine and is to start on Sunday (15th Feb).
Elsewhere, Gilts (-60 ticks) are underperforming in fixed income markets on the back of the BoE Quarterly Inflation Report, while T-Notes and Bunds are also lower, partially due to equity strength, with US traders await the final Treasury auction of the week in the form of USD 16bln in a 30yr note.
In FX, markets have seen abnormal volatility today, with the key event being the BoE’s Quarterly Inflation Report in which the MPC members revised down their short term CPI forecasts as a consequence of the fall in oil prices however stated that they expect inflation to rise back above the 2% target in the 2 year horizon. Other factors of the report that were perceived to be hawkish were that both growth and wages are set to increase and spare capacity will be eliminated within 18 months, compared to a forecast of 2-3 years at the last report. This saw GBP/USD climb above 1.5300 to mark the pairs highest level of the week while the EUR/GBP cross trades at 7 year lows.
Elsewhere, SEK weakened aggressively on the back of an unexpected 10bps rate cut from the Riksbank to -0.10%, after 12 of the 18 surveyed predicted that rates would be held. The announcement also saw the central bank state that they are to buy SEK 10bln of government bonds further exacerbating the weakness in the currency. Meanwhile, JPY strengthened this morning after comments from sources claiming that the BoJ thinks any additional stimulus will be ‘counter-productive’, which saw USD/JPY fall by over 60 pips in an initial fast money move to break back below the 120.00 level.
Finally, looking at commodities, oil prices have been strengthening during this morning’s session, aided by the weakening USD (-0.3%) to rebound from the lows yesterday, which saw WTI crude futures fall below the USD 50.00 handle after DoE inventories showed a larger build than expected (4868K vs. Exp. 3750K, Prev. 6333K).
Elsewhere, the metals complex sees gold experiencing a mild gain amid continued Greece concerns with prices remaining near 5 week lows after USD strength pressured the precious metal yesterday. Elsewhere, silver prices were notably lower amid technical selling with spot prices breaking below both the 50 DMA (USD 16.76/oz) and 100 DMA (USD 16.72/oz). JP Morgan sees gold falling by year end because of stronger USD, low inflation and low commodity prices however it may see some support on geo-political risks and seasonal demand. JPM think palladium and platinum looks cheap and palladium could be the best performer this year.
On today’s calendar, we get the retail sales print for January with the market expecting more energy related weakness at the headline. Jobless claims data is also due up and it’ll be interesting to see if the four-week average stays below 300k. Finally business inventories rounds off today’s releases.
Bulletin Headline Summary
- Russia-Ukraine ceasefire helps boost sentiment around Europe after Greek stalemate overnight
- GBP spikes higher as the BoE’s Quarterly Inflation Report had a hawkish tone with growth and wages set to rise and slack in the economy to be eliminated faster than previously forecasted
- Looking ahead, out of the US today we have Advanced Retail Sales, weekly jobless data and a host of earnings, including AIG
- Treasuries fall, 30Y yields rise for sixth day before before quarterly refunding concludes with $16b long bonds; WI bid yield 2.63%, second lowest on record, vs record- low 2.43% award in January.
- USTs in mid-January began a seasonally bearish period lasting into the May refunding; 10Y yields breaking above 2% could target 2.08%, then 2.19% near term, ED&F Man head of rates and credit Tom di Galoma writes in note
- The leaders of Russia, Ukraine, Germany and France agreed on a cease-fire to stem the conflict that’s devastated eastern Ukraine and triggered the worst crisis in more than 20 years between Russia and its former Cold War foes
- EU leaders will take up the baton on Greece when they gather in Brussels today after finance ministers postponed decisions on country’s future financing until next week
- Greek lenders have almost exhausted Emergency Liquidity Assistance they received from the European Central Bank via the Bank of Greece, Skai Television reports in its evening news bulletin, without saying how it got the information
- Sweden’s central bank cut its main rate below zero and unveiled additional measures designed to jolt the largest Nordic economy out of a deflationary spiral
- Bank of England Governor Mark Carney signaled rates may increase faster than investors had anticipated as Britain’s economy gathers pace
- Bank of Japan policy makers view further monetary easing to shore up inflation as a counterproductive step for now, amid concern it could trigger declines in the yen that damage confidence, people familiar with the talks said
- The number of energy jobs cut globally have climbed well above 100,000 as once-bustling oil hubs in Scotland, Australia and Brazil, among other countries, empty out, according to Swift Worldwide Resources, a staffing firm
- Kaisa Group Holdings bonds slid after co. said lenders and bondholders “should not expect payments of principal and interest according to existing terms”
- Sovereign yields mostly lower; Greece 10Y falls ~23bps. Asian, European stocks gain, U.S. equity-index futures higher. Brent and WTI higher, gold and copper gain
Hoping to make some more sense of the overnight depressive euphoria is DB’s Jim Reid with his overnight recap
There may also be some sleepless nights ahead for European leaders after a stalemate yesterday after a late session and hours of talks at the Eurogroup meeting. The result largely lived up to our expectations with both Greece and Eurozone finance ministers failing to agree on an outcome. Instead, talks now move onto Monday’s Eurogroup meeting. The lack of any material outcome was summed up in a very short press conference shortly after in which both Greece and the Euro officials failed to agree on a joint statement – the Greek side rejecting language that might be seen as agreeing to an extension of the current programme. Head of the Eurogroup finance ministers Dijesslbloem said in the press conference after that ‘we covered a lot of ground but didn’t actually reach a joint conclusion on how to take the next steps’ and that ‘there has to be political agreement on the way forward’. Varoufakis meanwhile was quoted in the Greek press Ekathimerini shortly after the meeting as saying that ‘we explained why this bailout is not working’ and that ‘we want a new contract with Europe’.
Our resident expert George Saravelos believes that irrespective of today’s outcome, we now have some more visibility over how Monday could potentially play out. On the one hand Europe is offering a technical extension of the existing program and on the hand Greece is looking for maximum flexibility and the least amount of up-front commitments attached to completing the program review. George still believes that an agreement to move forward should be achievable but that successful completion in agreeing on the terms will be a close call given the large distance still clearly between Greece and European officials. Of course, failure to agree on moving forward on Monday or a deadlock will shift focus to next Wednesday’s ELA review by the ECB, where, in the event of failure we could see the ECB become more explicit on timing of potential ELA withdrawal.
The other focus last night was the Ukraine and Russia talks and as we go to print reports are breaking that leaders from France, Germany, Russia and Ukraine are set to sign an agreement according to Reuters. The talks have gone on for most of the night but the early signs appear to be positive and we are expecting a conference imminently. Staying on the Ukraine, we also heard from the IMF’s Lagarde yesterday who was quoted on Bloomberg saying that the IMF is ‘very close’ to a bailout agreement for Ukraine. An official announcement is expected this morning at 9am CET.
With the outcome of the meeting coming after close in the US, markets this morning have rebounded off the early weakness from the Greece news and bourses are trading firmer as we type – reflecting the breaking headlines from the Ukraine talks. The Hang Seng (+0.45%), Shanghai Composite (+0.33%) and Nikkei (+1.53%) are all firmer – the latter in part benefiting from strong machine orders data – whilst bourses in Taiwan and Korea have also rebounded off the day’s lows in recent moments. The Euro is 0.2% weaker versus the Dollar in trading this morning, having initially swung around last night with various headlines.
Before the Eurogroup meeting yesterday, markets were subdued in the US with the S&P 500 eventually closing unchanged on what turned out to be the third lowest volume day this year. The index did in fact trade as low as -0.5% intraday before paring losses into the close. It did cross into positive territory briefly as headlines over Greece began to emerge from the Eurogroup meeting. Energy stocks (-0.66%) declined as oil markets fell for a second consecutive day. WTI (-2.36%) and Brent (-3.14%) fell to $48.84/bbl and $54.66/bbl respectively after the latest IEA report which showed crude supplies rising to record levels once again last week. The earlier hopes of US production cuts do appear to have been put to one side for now.
Treasuries were also quiet up until the Eurogroup headlines started to leak. Although the 10y benchmark yield closed 2bps wider at 2.018%, the yield did at one point touch an intraday low of 1.969% during the meeting. Meanwhile the Dollar ended the day unchanged with the DXY having earlier traded some +0.36% firmer before declining in the last hour of trading. Data-wise it was quiet with just the monthly budget statement for January which saw a smaller than expected deficit at $17.5bn (vs. expectations of a deficit of $19bn). Fedspeak caught the eye once more however. The Dallas Fed’s Fisher was quoted on Bloomberg with regards to raising rates saying that ‘I wanted it to happen in March, and I lost the argument’.
It was a similar subdued picture in Europe earlier in the day. The Stoxx 600 finished the day 0.24% weaker whilst the DAX (-0.02%) finished more or less unchanged. Credit markets also closed generally flat. Greek assets were notably weaker in the lead up to the meeting however with Greek equities closing 4% weaker and 3y yields widening some 130bps. With little in the way of data, the market appeared to be in something of a wait and see mode for Greece. 10y Bund yields finished 1.5bps tighter at 0.353% and Spanish and Italian yields were 2-4bps wider. The Euro meanwhile finished 0.13% firmer at $1.1335 however in reality it bounced around with the end of day headlines. Elsewhere, having highlighted some examples of record low yields in recent reports, Switzerland yesterday sold CHF 10y bonds at a yield of just 0.011% – the lowest of any country on record.
It’s a busier day data wise today as the calendar picks up. The final inflation reading for Germany will likely be the highlight this morning with the market expecting a -0.3% yoy headline print. Industrial production for the Euro-area will also be worth keeping an eye on and we also get the BoE inflation report out of the UK and the Riksbank monetary policy decision. In the US this afternoon we’ve got the retail sales print for January with the market expecting more energy related weakness at the headline. Jobless claims data is also due up and it’ll be interesting to see if the four-week average stays below 300k. Finally business inventories rounds off today’s releases.
end
Last night the Swedish Central bank, the world’s oldest central bank and 4th oldest bank (formed in 1668) decided to lower its interest rate by 10 basis points to -10 %. It is also doing QE as they are buying an additional 10 billion SEK worth of bonds:
(courtesy zero hedge)
Sweden Central Joins The NIRP Club: Lowers Interest Rate To -0.1%, Launches QE
It’s a NIRP world and you are either in it, or are determined to lose the currency wars. And hours ago, the world’s oldest central bank, that of Sweden, announced that it too would join its NIRP peers in an attempt to preserve its currency’s fighting power in the global currency wars which make a mockery of what is going on in Ukraine, by lowering the benchmark interest rate to -0.1%, but also launch QE by buying SEK 10 billion of government bonds, thereby making sure that the stock of available debt in private hands is even lower and that central banks monetize even more than merely “all” of all net issuance in 2015.
From the press release:
There are signs that underlying inflation has bottomed out, but the situation abroad is now more uncertain and this increases the risk that inflation will not rise sufficiently fast. The Executive Board of the Riksbank has therefore decided to cut the repo rate by 0.10 percentage points, to -0.10 per cent, and to adjust the repo-rate path down somewhat. At the same time, the interest rates on the fine-tuning transactions in the Riksbank’s operational framework for the implementation of monetary policy are being restored to the repo rate +/- 0.10 percentage point. Moreover, the Riksbank will buy government bonds for the sum of SEK 10 billion. These measures and the readiness to do more at short notice underline that the Riksbank’ is safeguarding the role of the inflation target as a nominal anchor for price setting and wage formation.
Economic activity in Sweden strengthening but inflation is too low
Although the recovery abroad is slow, growth in Sweden will benefit from the low oil prices, the weaker krona and the very low repo rate. GDP growth is expected to increase at a faster pace in the coming period and the labour market is expected to strengthen.
Inflation is still low, but there are now signs that underlying inflation, for instance, the CPIF excluding energy, has bottomed out and is rising. The krona is weaker than anticipated, which will also contribute to somewhat higher inflation. However, low energy prices are expected to hold down CPIF inflation in the year immediately ahead.
Readiness to do more
The measures the Riksbank is now taking underline that the Riksbank is safeguarding the role of the inflation target as a nominal anchor for price setting and wage formation. To ensure that inflation rises towards the target, the Riksbank is prepared to quickly make monetary policy more expansionary, even between the ordinary monetary policy meetings, should the need arise. This will primarily entail making further repo-rate cuts, postponing the first repo-rate increase and increasing the purchases of government bonds. In addition, there is the possibility of a programme of loans to companies via the banks.
As the WSJ adds, analysts were divided ahead of the rate decision about which way it would go. A small majority expected unchanged rates while others had forecast the repo rate could be cut as low as minus 0.25%. In response to the move, the Swedish krona weakened against the euro, which rose to around 9.65 kronor from 9.50 kronor.
It’s called NIRP for a reason: “Sweden’s two-year bond, which is more responsive to monetary policy changes than longer-dated bonds, traded at a yield of minus 0.23% after the decision compared with minus 0.18% before.”
While it is unclear if NIRP is the missing link that will fix all that ails the deflating Swedish economy, one thing is clear: the Riskbank has just given the all clear to BTFATH:
But no matter just how drastic this latest market intervention by yet another central bank, most wanted “moar”
Analysts were initially underwhelmed by the scale of the bond-buying program, known as quantitative easing, but noted the Riksbank’s comment that it is ready to do more in between scheduled meetings.
“Give me 10 billion kronor and I’ll say thank you very much but it’s the smallest quantitative easing ever,” said Société Générale analyst Kit Juckes.
SEB analyst Carl Hammer said he thought 10 billion kronor could be “just the beginning,” noting “they left the door open.”
Analysts at Nordea bank said the overall message from the Riksbank was “extremely soft.”
And sure enough, when this initial attempt to boost stock prices, pardon, inflation is found to be lacking, expect to see much more.
end
Greece goes on the offensive today and demands Draghi to monetize more Greek bonds along with other bonds from the periphery to stimulate the economy as rumours spread that they reached their limit 0f 60 billion Euros of ELA support (and maximum of 15 billion euros of treasury bill issuance).
(courtesy zero hedge)
Greece To ECB: “Get To Work, Mr. Draghi”
With talk that Greek banks have hit their emergency lending limit with the ECB (which has prompted a teleconference this morning among ECB polcy-makers), it seems the newly-found position of negotiating strength for Greece (perhaps encouraged by China or Russia behind the scenes) has prompted more demands:
- GREECE’S SYRIZA CHIEF ECONOMIST JOHN MILIOS PROPOSES OVERALL EURO ZONE DEBT OVERHANG REDUCTION BY ECB
- ECB COULD BUY ALL EURO ZONE DEBT MATURING IN 2016-2020 AND ALL INTEREST PAYMENTS-SYRIZA’S MILIOS
- ECB WOULD FOOT THE BILL NOW, BUT BY 2040 IT WOULD BE ABLE TO ERASE ALL LOSSES THROUGH PROFIT RETENTION-MILIOS
Roughly translated – “Get back to work, Mr.Draghi”and monetize all of Europe’s debt. With negative net issuance (i.e. central banks already monetizing over 100% of 2015’s expected issuance) already here, this demand merely pushes the ‘independent’ monetary policymakers to enable more fiscal profligacy.
Greek bank liquidity running dry…
The ECB moved Greek banks onto ELA last week after it ended a waiver on the quality of the nation’s debt it accepts as collateral amid doubts that the newly elected government will conclude its aid program.
Greek banks have almost exhausted the 59.5 billion euros granted by the ECB, Skai Television reported yesterday, without saying how it got the information.
And so ECB policymakers are discussing what to do next… (as Reuters reports)
European Central Bank policymakers held a telephone conference on Thursday concerning the provision of Emergency Liquidity Assistance (ELA) to banks in Greece, two people familiar with the matter told Reuters.
The ECB has authorised Greece’s national central bank to provide the country’s lenders with some 60 billion euros ($68.08 billion) in ELA, people familiar with the matter have said, but this requires regular approval from the ECB’s Governing Council.
The ECB declined to comment, when asked about the telephone conference.
ELA provision is critical to the fate of Greece’s banks, and in turn the country’s fate, after the ECB cancelled its acceptance of Greek bonds in return for funding last week.
* * *
The question is – does The ‘independent’ ECB play hard ball and squeeze Greek banks by withholding more funding to aid Eurogropup negotiations into Monday? For now, Greek bank bonds and stocks are notably higher (for what reason is anyone’s guess)…
Last night a ceasefire was agreed to by all sides. I wonder how long this will last!! The IMF supposedly is set to give a 4 year restructuring deal.
The amount is equivalent to 15 billion euros. That amount will not last long. Its currency the UAH has fallen to 25 UAH to the dollar from 15 to the dollar. Hyperinflation is already setting into the Ukraine.
end
The latest calendar of events with respect to Greece and the EU:
(courtesy zero hedge)
Greece: Another Big Picture Update And The Latest Calendar Of Events
Confused by the whirlwind of conflicting facts, not to mention outright lies, leaks and rumors, surrounding the negotiations of what will either be the third Greek bailout of its first, and final, Greek exit from the Eurozone? The following summary should answer most questions.
From DB’s George Saravelos
The Emergency Eurogroup on Greece concluded late Wednesday evening with little progress being made. On the positive side, expectations were very low – all sides had suggested that no agreement should be expected today. On the negative side, it appears that the meeting concluded with the prospect that a joint Greece – Eurogroup statement could be signed by both sides. However, agreement on the phrasing of this statement broke down, with the Greek side ultimately rejecting the language as equivalent to an extension of the existing program – something which the prime minister explicitly ruled out in the Greek parliament a few days ago.
Semantics may be playing a role here, as the Greek side would clearly prefer a re-branded “bridge program” that may be more acceptable domestically. Substance cannot however be overlooked: the Greek prime minister has explicitly distinguished between a legal extension of the “loan agreement” (which the government desires and relates to funding disbursement) and a rejection of an extension of the “program”, which includes all the policy conditionality attached to financial assistance. Ultimately, the key difference between the two sides is that Greece doesn’t want to commit to the policy conditionality specified under the existing program, while the European side is requesting the opposite.
Irrespective of today’s outcome, we now have a little more visibility around how the debate will evolve into Monday’s Eurogroup meeting: the European side is offering a technical extension of the existing program (rather than our initial expectation of a 3rdrd ESM program), with the Greek side desiring maximum flexibility and the least amount of up-front commitments attached to completing the program review.
Our baseline remains that an agreement to move forward should be achievable. After all, this will only involve a commonly agreed written statement by both sides that marks the first step in a three-part process:
- Step 1 consists of agreeing on a negotiating framework around which talks can begin (“the program extension”).
- Step 2 will then involve the actual negotiation over the fiscal path, structural reforms and debt sustainability (“the policy conditionality around the program”).
- Step 3 then requires the approval of any program conditionality by the Greek parliament before any formal disbursements to Greece are made.
Given the large distance separating the two sides, we view the successful completion of each of the three steps as a close call. Agreement at the Eurogroup on Monday will allow substantive negotiations to start, but any additional interim funding to Greece via increased t-bill issuance (if at all) is unlikely to be approved until progress on talks has been achieved. A continuation of the deadlock on Monday will immediately shift focus to Wednesday’s bi-weekly ECB review of the ELA limits of Greek banks: in the event of failure, we would expect the ECB to become more explicit on the timing of when ELA funding would be withdrawn or capped.
Ultimately, the alternative of ELA withdrawal and eventual capital controls for Greece is worse for all sides involved. But whether progress can be achieved under very pressing deadlines and large differences of opinion on the underlying policy path between the two sides remains to be seen.
Updated calendar
- Thursday February 12th – European Council of EU Leaders, Tsipras likely to meet Merkel on sidelines
- Sunday February 15th – Voting for new Greek President begins, EC Commissioner Avramopoulos most likely candidate, originating from New Democracy. Likely completed by second round on the following day requiring 151 MP majority
- Monday February 16th – Eurogroup
- Wednesday February 18th – Bi-weekly ELA review
- Tuesday February 24th – 595mio EUR of bond interest/principal due
- Saturday February 28th – Current EFSF program expires
- 6th March – 297mio EUR IMF repayment due / 1.2bn EUR t-bill matures
- 13th March – 334mio EUR IMF repayment due / 1.6bn EUR t-bill matures
- 16th March – 556mio EUR IMF repayment due
- 20th March – 334mio EUR IMF repayment due / 111mio EUR bond interest/principal due / 1.6bn EUR t- bill matures
end
The rumours are true: the ECB hikes the ELA to 65 billion euros by raising the amount of money that they can raise via the treasury bill route:
(courtesy zero hedge)
Stealth Greek Bank Run Continues: ECB Hikes Emergency Lending To EUR 65 Billion
It would appear the un-sourced rumors of Greek banks having used up their Emergency line of credit with the ECB are true. Following a hastily put together conference calls this morning:
- *ECB RAISES GREECE ELA ALLOWANCE TO EU65BN: FAZ
Up from the previous EUR59.5 Billion. It appears the stealth bank run in Greece is showing no signs of slowing.
As Reuters repiorted yesterday,
The ECB moved Greek banks onto ELA last week after it ended a waiver on the quality of the nation’s debt it acceptsas collateral amid doubts that the newly elected government will conclude its aid program.
Greek banks have almost exhausted the 59.5 billion euros granted by the ECB, Skai Television reported yesterday, without saying how it got the information.
And so today, as Bloomberg reports,
*ECB DECIDED ON GREEK ELA ALLOWANCE IN TELEPHONE CONFERENCE: FAZ
The ECB’s Governing Council held a phone conference Thursday to raise the allowance for the Greek central bank to provide Emergency Liquidity Assistance by 5 billion euros, FAZ reports, without saying where it got the information
end
War of words: ECB’s Noyer admits to the world that the GREXIT would be very painful.
It demands Greece to negotiate seriously ????
(courtesy zero hedge)
ECB’S Noyer Admits Grexit Would Be “Very Painful”, Demands Greece “Negotiate Seriously”
Despite media claims that the German-Greek relationship did not “look tense” at today’s EU leaders’ meeting; and in spite of the European market’s seeming exuberance at no deal but a possible deal but no deal, ECB’s Noyer has come out swinging:
- *NOYER SAYS GREECE NEEDS TO NEGOTIATE SERIOUSLY
- *NOYER SAYS GREEK EXIT FROM EURO WOULD BE `VERY PAINFUL’
This is odd in that markets have been managed to prove Grexit is ‘contained’.. Noyer added that the Emergency lending agreement (ELA) is adapted to the needs of the economy, and ironically explained Greece needed to focus on growth (ironic because Greece is expected to grow notably faster that eurozone this year).
end
Germany blinks;
still looks a little far fetched..
(courtesy zero hedge)
Greek Gambit Succeeds As Germany Said To Ease Bailout Terms
With tax receipts tumbling and ELA funding hitting its limit, the Greeks are up against it. On the other side, the Greek strength in the face of EU’s demands (and Eurogroup’s realization of the uncertainty this could lead to) has apparently led to the start of compromise. As Bloomberg reports,
- *GERMAN, GREEK OFFICIALS SIGNAL COMMON GROUND ON AID DEAL
- *GERMANY SAID NOT TO INSIST ALL PARTS OF CURRENT BAILOUT STAY
- *GREECE SAID TO BE OPEN TO SURPLUS, PRIVATIZATION DEBATE
As Merkel noted earlier, “Europe is always about finding a compromise,” and it appears they are getting closer – as long as a ‘program’ continues. Bundesbank’s Weidmann has noted that Grexit would not solve either side’s longer-term problems.
Greece and Germany are pursuing a deal on the conditions required to continue the Greek bailout as each side signals a willingness to compromise, according to government officials taking part in the talks.
Germany won’t insist that all elements of Greece’s current aid program continue,said two officials in Berlin. As long as the program is prolonged, they said, Germany would be open to talking about the size of Greece’s budget surplus requirement and conditions to sell off government assets.
For its part, Greece is prepared to commit to a primary budget surplus, as long as it’s lower than the current 4 percent of gross domestic product, according to Greek government officials.Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras’s coalition also might be willing to compromise on privatizations, one of the officials said.
All the officials asked not to be named because the deliberations are private and ongoing.
* * *
Merkel added:
“You make compromises when the advantages outweigh the disadvantages.Germany is ready for that, but you also have to say that Europe’s credibility depends on us sticking to the rules and that we deal with each other in a reliable way.”
So to summarize: Greece fails on its ‘promise’ to uphold one-third of its program’s requirements but because it upheld two-thirds, Germany insists that shows commitment and supports Merkele’s earlier comments that “Europe’s credibility depends on us sticking to the rules.”
Brilliant!
end
Then late this evening, the tone certainly did not look like it was compromise-prone:
(courtesy zero hedge)
Dijsselbloem Pours Cold Water On Greek Compromise: “Don’t Get Your Hopes Up”
Just over an hour ago, what appears to have been a strawman now was issued by Bloomberg via leaked sources from Greek and German officials that proclaimed talk of a “compromise” deal that makes everyone happy in Europe. However, as the leaders exited today’s summit,the tone of their responses did not exactly sound compromise-prone:
- *DIJSSELBLOEM SAYS GREECE PROCESS GOING TO BE V. DIFFICULT, “DON’T GET YOUR HOPES UP YET” ON GREECE
- *MERKEL URGES GREECE TO MAKE UP ITS MIND SOON ON FINANCING
Hardly the resoundingly positive spin we saw earlier. Poland’s Tusk, Finland’s Stubb, and good old Juncker also chimed in with the latter commenting on Greece’s “anti-social” behavior. Tsipras made some neutral statements, then came out swinging, “The MoU as we knew it is over. The same goes for the troika. All these years, the burden fell on the poorest. Our aim is to restore the sense of justice.”
Juncker
“We have heard that the Greek government wants to cancel some measures ‘cos they are antisocial. Indeed, they may be antisocial.”
Eurogroup
- *DIJSSELBLOEM SAYS `DON’T GET YOUR HOPES UP YET’ ON GREECE
- *DIJSSELBLOEM SAYS `VERY CAUTIOUS’ ON GREECE
- *DIJSSELBLOEM SAYS GREECE PROCESS GOING TO TAKE TIME
- *DIJSSELBLOEM SAYS GREECE PROCESS GOING TO BE V. DIFFICULT
“I’m very cautious on the political side, it’s going to be very difficult and it’s going to take time and don’t get your hopes up yet”
“The technical assessment will be a comparison to see what the common ground is between the current program and the political program of the new Greek government. The Greek minister has said before that he thinks 70 percent of the current program he could take for his responsibility. So we could look at the 70 percent, we could also look at the 30 percent; what has to come out, what could be put in place and these have to of course be valid measures and that’s the kind of work we’re going to do this weekend and maybe we can make some political progress again on Monday.”
Germany
- *MERKEL SAYS TSIPRAS MADE GENERAL STATEMENT ON GREECE GOALS
- *MERKEL URGES GREECE TO MAKE UP ITS MIND SOON ON FINANCING
Finland
- *STUBB SAYS CONVERSATION ON GREECE WAS `VERY GOOD’
- *STUBB SEES GREECE PROPOSAL BY MONDAY
“We had a very good conversation and discussion about a possible avenue and path forward and I am sure that they will be working on some kind of a program with the institutions over the coming days and put forward the proposals on Monday”
Poland
- *TUSK SAYS EU LEADERS DIDN’T ENTER INTO NEGOTIATIONS ON GREECE
* * *
Then Tsipras spoke:
- *TSIPRAS SAYS DIJSSELBLOEM STATEMENT IS POSITIVE STEP FOR GREECE
- *TSIPRAS: EUROGROUP TO DISCUSS MONDAY TRANSITION TO NEW PROGRAM
- *TSIPRAS SAYS GREEK DEBT PROBLEM NEEDS TO BE TACKLED
- *TSIPRAS VOWS TO TACKLE VESTED INTERESTS IN GREECE
- *TSIPRAS SAYS NO ONE WANTS TO CREATE RIFT WITHIN THE EURO AREA
- *TSIPRAS SAYS GREECE IS `SPECIAL CASE’ AMONG BAILOUT COUNTRIES
“The MoU as we knew it is over. The same goes for the troika.”
“All these years, the burden fell on the poorest. Our aim is to restore the sense of justice.”
end
The following was written before the announcement that Germany has blinked. The key point in the following Meijer paper is that a GREXIT will have a devastating effect on the EU and its members:
(courtesy Raul Meijer/the Automatic Earth)
The Greek Issue Just Got Personal
Submitted by Raul Ilargi Meijer via The Automatic Earth blog,
It was already present over the past two weeks, for example in Yanis Varoufakis’ meetings with Eurogroup head Jeroen Dijsselbloem and German FinMin Schäuble, awkwardly obvious in facial expressions and body language. A touch of personal discomfort. A touch of a threat that required chest-thumping and hubris to be brushed off. ‘You better do what we say or else’. Back then, perhaps it was still experienced from a political, deal-making, perspective. But in the course of yesterday it became clear something has changed.
It has become personal, you could feel it in the air, and that raises the danger level considerably. It’s not personal from the Greek side; Alexis Tsipras and Varoufakis merely act according to – their interpretation of – the mandate handed them by their voters. It’s the other side(s) that have started making it personal. They see themselves, their positions, as being under attack. And they blame Greece’s new Syriza government for that. Which may seem logical at first blush, but that doesn’t make it true. The people sitting on the other side from Varoufakis have dug themselves into these positions.
Which, as they rightfully fear, are now threatened.Not because Syriza means to do so, but because they come to the table with that mandate, to put an end to what has caused Greece to sink as deep as it has. There’s nothing personal about that, it’s democracy at work, it’s politics. Still, it’s perceived as personal, because it makes the ‘old’ leadership uncomfortable. They haven’t seen it coming, they were convinced, all the way, that they would prevail. They mostly still are, but in a now much more nervous fashion.
It’s started to dawn on them that perhaps Syriza will not back down on its demands, that yet another – mostly superficial – political deal is not in the cards. CNBC reported last night that a deal on an extension of the existing bailout was near, and markets reacted quite strongly. It would appear, therefore, that both media and investors have been as deaf as the EU to what Syriza has been consistently saying, that it’s not interested in such an extension. It was never on the table, not from the Greek point of view.
Perhaps a headline such as yesterday’s ‘Greece Warned To Expect No Favors’ sums it up best. The EU side sees – or at least publicly presents – any negotiation with Greece as handing out favors, while Syriza says it doesn’t want any favors, it wants something that will give the Greek people back a future. And there is nothing that will make them not want that.
There is of course a fear within the EU that what is granted to Greece will eventually also have to be handed to other countries. Interestingly, though, the incumbent governments of the countries involved, Spain, Portugal, Italy, have a vested interest in Syriza failing. Because if it doesn’t, their powers are set to dwindle. This is most urgently obvious in Spain, where PM Rajoy’s ruling party is already way behind Podemos in the polls.
Podemos leader Pablo Iglesias, writing in the Guardian, made his position very clear:
If The Greek Olive Branch Is Rejected, Europe May Fall
During his swearing-in speech as Greece’s prime minister, Alexis Tsipras was clear: “Our aim is to achieve a solution that is mutually beneficial for both Greece and our partners. Greece wants to pay its debt.” The European Central Bank’s response to the Greek government’s desire to be conciliatory and responsible, was also very clear: negative. Either the Greek government abandons the programme on which it was elected, and continues to do the very thing that has been disastrous for Greece, or the ECB will stop supporting Greek debt.
The ECB’s calculation is not only arrogant, it is incoherent. The same central bank that recognised its mistakes a few weeks ago and began to buy government debt is now denying financing to the very states that have been arguing for years that the role of a central bank should be to back up governments in protecting their citizens rather than to rescue the financial bodies that caused the crisis.
And though Portugal may not – yet – have a full-fledged Syriza or Podemos, it’s economy is in straits as dire as those of its peers, as Ambrose EP explains today:
Germany Faces Impossible Choice As Greek Austerity Revolt Spreads
It is unfair to pick on Portugal but its public and private debts are 380% of GDP – the highest in Europe and higher than those of Greece – making is acutely vulnerable to toxic effects of deflation on debt dynamics. Portugal’s net international investment position (NIIP) – the best underlying indicator of solvency – has reached minus 112% of GDP. Public debt has jumped from 111% to 125% of GDP in three years. The fiscal deficit is still 5%. The country’s ranking in global competitiveness is close to that of Greece.
“The situation in Portugal is very different,” says Paulo Portas, the deputy premier. Sadly it is not. Once you violate the sanctity of monetary union and reduce EMU to a fixed-exchange system, the illusion that Portugal is out of the woods may not last long. Markets will test it. Only two people can now stop the coming train-wreck. Chancellor Angela Merkel and her finance minister Wolfgang Schauble, a man who masks his passion for the EU cause behind an irascible front.
Ambrose also quotes Italy’s Beppe Grillo:
Beppe Grillo’s Five Star movement – with 108 seats in parliament – is openly calling for a return to the lira. Mr Grillo proclaims that Syriza is carrying the torch for all the long-suffering peoples of southern Europe, as it is in a sense. “What’s happening to Greece today, will be happening to Italy tomorrow. Sooner or later, default is coming,” he said.
Maybe for the reigning ‘kings and queens’ of the EU and its member states it’s inevitable that all this should become personal at some point. They’ve certainly tried hard enough to trivialize Grillo as some kind of clown through the years. Perhaps, also, it’s the demeanor, the popularity and the person of Varoufakis, the ‘new heart-throb of the thinking German woman’, as Ambrose characterized him. And I don’t think he meant Angela Merkel. Christine Lagarde, perhaps, who showed up yesterday in the sort of attire that seemed designed to blend in with Yanis.
But I still think the main reason things got personal is that with the arrival of Syriza on the scene, the ‘kings and queens’ can just ‘intuitively smell’ the changes that are afoot, and that don’t spell anything good for their own plush seats. For a while they could pretend it was all only – mostly right-wing – extremists that expressed feelings critical of the EU. And of course, Syriza is still habitually labeled ‘extreme left wing’ and ‘Marxist’, but Varoufakis clearly isn’t seen by people in Germany et al as some extremist nutcase.
The usual bag of tricks no longer works. And the subject Varoufakis brings to the table, that the EU and ECB economical policies have been an abject failure – at least for the people in Greece’ Main Street – is not some extreme notion either. Schäuble and Dijsselbloem can try and cling to the idea that Greece seeks to swindle German and Dutch voters out of even more money than they already have, and that still works to an extent, but it is wearing thin.
The contagion from Syriza success can be considerable, and though it pretends otherwise, the EU has no idea what it would mean down the line.Every single option they look at that is NOT Varoufakis surrendering, must scare them out of their socks. Anything they give up will be seen as a sign of weakness, and it will encourage parties for which Syriza ‘carries the torch’, and likely raise their support and votes.
However, if the Eurogroup don’t give up anything at all in the negotiations, there may be a Grexit, even with Russia and/or China stepping in to fund Athens. While there are all sorts of reports claiming that Grexit is manageable for the EU, don’t believe a word of them: nobody knows. And none of the present big shots wants to be held responsible for blowing up the common currency.
They have come to the realization over the past week that Syriza can be a ground-breaking force in Europe, not just a minor nuisance. They will have to adapt their attitude and their way of thinking, real fast. Monday February 16 comes to mind. Because Syriza will not back down and go for a bailout extension. For the simple reason that it is not what they see as their mandate. The Eurogroup had better be prepared for that, or it might become irrelevant in no time.
And no, no matter what they think, it’s not personal.Not for Varoufakis it isn’t. He merely represents the Greeks without access to health care who line up at soup kitchens. But you’re right, for those people, living in the third world that Europe has created within its borders, it’s very personal.
end
Early this morning, the Ukraine and the rebels reached a deal with a ceasefire. The details are provided below. The IMF is set to give 17.5 billion USA in aid to the Ukraine. However today, the UAH fell again to 26.5 UAH/dollar.
(courtesy zero hedge)
Ukraine Ceasefire Deal Agreed After Negotiations All-Nighter; Doubts Remain About Its Implementation
It would have simply been too much to handle for Europe and the risk off algos if hours after the embarrassing failure of the emergency Eurogroup meeting in Brussels failed to reach any deal involving Greece, the Ukraine ceasefire negotiations in Minsk were also to fall apart.Again. Which is probably why after a marathon session lasting 17 hours, and following repeated trial balloons that a deal had and/or had not been reached, a short while ago all major media outlets were delighted to finally blast some Risk On news namely that leaders of France and Germany brokered a renewed deal to end Ukraine’s 10-month civil war in the separatist eastern region, which means that we have a Minsk-signed Ukraine ceasefire.Again.
As the WSJ reports, “details of the agreement weren’t immediately available” but it involves a cease-fire starting on February 15, Sunday, with each side pulling back heavy weapons, as well as steps to give greater autonomy to the Russia-backed separatist regions in eastern Ukraine. All negotiators, namely Ukraine’s Petro Poroshenko, Russia’s Vladimir Putin, Germany’s Angela Merkel, and France’s Francois Hollande said there are no alternatives to peaceful solution.
Some more from Bloomberg according to which Ukraine would start getting border control day after regional elections and full control after constitutional reforms, including decentralization, according to copy of document signed by contact group in Minsk, Belarus.
- Cease-fire to start Feb. 15, midnight Sat. to Sun. in Kiev
- Accord sets amnesty covering conflict in Donetsk, Luhansk regions
- Accord sets a minimum 50km buffer zone, 70-140km for missile systems;
withdrawal set from front line as of Sept. 19 for rebels, current front
line for Ukraine army - Ukraine to pass constitutional reforms, including permanent special status to Donetsk, Luhansk, by end-2015
- Ukraine to restore economic ties, banking links, pension, social benefits to east
- Withdrawal of heavy artillery to start no later than 2nd day after cease-fire starts; to be completed w/in 14 days
- Agree to create oversight mechanism to ensure peace accord is implemented
- Agree to support 3-way talks w/ Ukraine, Russia, EU on gas supplies
- Germany, France to help rebuild banking system in Ukraine regions affected by conflict
- All “illegal” groups to disarm
Ukraine’s president Poroshenko was quick to preempt accusations that this was yet another major concession by Ukraine which has already ceded Crimea to Russia – a topic that was not touched with a ten foot pole -and said that there will be no autonomy for the separatist, natural gas and industry-heavy Donbas region and that the agreement won’t move to federalization. Still one can’t quite explain the 50km buffer zone, whose purpose is not exactly clear if not to provide precisely that: autonomy.
Others were quick to point out that the agreement was not really a breakthrough, such as Germany’s foreign minister, Frank-Walter Steinmeier, who said in e-mail that parties to Minsk talks sought to gain more from agreement sealed Thursday but achieved most important goal of sealing ceasefire. “We achieved something while chance remains that Feb. 15 ceasefire accord could be upturned by intervening violence.”
“Today’s agreement is not a comprehensive solution and not at all a breakthrough” but added that the most “important” aim of ceasefire achieved in talks. “For the first time we have clear tasks with time allotments for the implementation of the Minsk obligations: on voting, border controls, exchanging prisoners among others.”
Others chimed in as well: “Much, much work is still necessary,” Ms. Merkel said after the talks ended. “But there is a real chance that things will turn for the better.” Merkel said both Mr. Putin and Mr. Poroshenko acted constructively in the negotiations.
“President Putin indeed did all he could to achieve the possibility of ending the bloodshed,” Ms. Merkel said. She added: “In the end, President Putin also put pressure on the separatists” to agree to a cease-fire taking effect Saturday night.
Merkel concludes by saying that “All things considered I would like to say that what we’ve reached now is giving us more hope than if we hadn’t agreed on anything. I don’t have any illusions, we don’t have any illusions that a lot of work is still required but there’s a real chance for things to take a turn for the better.”
Mr. Hollande described the pact as cause for “serious hope,” and said France and Germany had committed to verifying the implementation of the deal. “Everything is not yet accomplished, but this is a serious hope for Ukraine and a relief for Europe,” he said.
But the questions already emerged: the negotiations hit some snags along the way. Mr. Putin blamed the last-minute delay on what he called Ukraine’s refusal to negotiate directly with the separatist leaders. There was no immediate response from Kiev to that.
Mr. Putin also said one area of disagreement remained about the town of Debaltseve, where Ukrainian forces have been under siege from rebels for days. Separatist leaders called on Kiev’s forces to surrender and abandon the town, something Ukraine so far has refused to do.
By Mr. Putin’s account the agreement appears to split the difference on one key area of controversy—the dividing line between the two sides on the ground.
Mr. Putin said Kiev’s troops would pull back heavy weapons from the current front line, which reflects months of rebel gains, while the rebels would pull their equipment back from the line in the original September agreements.
Even before the negotiations had reached an agreement, the IMF sent out a notice that its staff had agreed on new US$ 17.5 billion extended fund facility with Ukraine.
“The mission has reached a staff-level agreement with the authorities on an economic reform program, which can be supported by a four-year Extended Fund Facility, in the amount of SDR 12.35 billion (about $17.5 billion, €15.5 billion), as well as, by considerable additional resources from the international community. The staff level agreement is subject to approval by IMF Management and the Executive Board. Consideration by the Executive Board is expected in the next few weeks, following the authorities’ implementation of decisive front-loaded actions to achieve program goals.
“The policies under the new arrangement, developed by the Ukrainian authorities jointly with Fund staff, are designed to address the many challenges confronting the Ukrainian economy. Economic activity contracted by around 7-7½ percent in GDP in 2014, weighed down by the conflict in Eastern Ukraine, which has taken a significant toll on the industrial base and exports, undermined confidence and ignited pressures on the financial system. The economic reform program focuses on immediate macroeconomic stabilization as well as broad and deep structural reforms to provide the basis for strong and sustainable economic growth over the medium term.
“The 2015 budget initiates an expenditure-led adjustment to strengthen public finances within the availability of resources. This required bold, but necessary, measures, including keeping nominal wages and pensions fixed. The budget is supported by revenue reforms, including increasing the progressivity of the personal income tax and streamlining the tax system. The authorities are committed to medium term reforms of the civil service and the important health and education sectors, aiming to improve quality and efficiency, as well as widening the tax base and improving customs and tax administration. Fiscal consolidation would continue over the coming years which together with the debt operation envisaged by the authorities will strengthen debt sustainability.
Alas, with Ukraine having no gold left, the probability of the IMF staying to implement a long-term structural reform in the country is slim to none which means hyperinflation is almost certainly inevitable, but while Ukraine may or may not have reached a (temporary) ceasefire, it will at least have the cash to pay for its external obligations. Mostly to Russia.
Finally, as a reminder, this is the second time Ukraine peace has been signed on paper in Minsk, only for hopes to crash and burn in the days that followed. Many are skeptical this time will not be different, most certainly if headlines such as the following continue to appear in the coming hours and days, until the actual ceasefire is implemented on Sunday.
end
The terms of the ceasefire
(courtesy Strafor)
The Terms Of The Ukraine Cease-Fire: Presenting “East Ukraine”
From Stratfor
The Terms of Ukraine’s Cease-Fire
Following marathon talks in Minsk that lasted more than 17 hours, the leaders of Germany, France, Russia and Ukraine reached an agreement that appears to align with the Kremlin’s demands. The document calls for a cease-fire to begin Feb. 15, the withdrawal of weapons and the enactment of constitutional reforms in Ukraine. Though Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko has denied that the agreement includes provisions for the creation of autonomous regions or the federalization of Ukraine, the document on the whole does fulfill several of the Kremlin’s long-standing demands with regards to the status of Donbas.
The new cease-fire agreement is based largely on the original one that went into effect Sept. 5. It focuses on the withdrawal of heavy artillery systems, which have been prominent throughout the conflict, within 14 days of the cease-fire’s implementation. The new cease-fire requires these artillery systems to be withdrawn far beyond their maximum effective ranges, a move that will create a buffer to prevent escalation and heavy artillery fire on the demarcation line. Missing from the agreement, however, is a decision on the fate of the still heavily contested Ukrainian positions in Debaltseve. Because both sides will have to withdraw their artillery systems, the result will be a very deep area without artillery cover in the center of the demarcation line.
The agreement’s most important impact on the military balance is its requirement to withdraw foreign forces and mercenaries from Ukraine. Separatists have depended heavily on the combat power of the Russian military and Russian volunteer forces. Without these, the separatists would have been incapable of repelling the Ukrainian offensive, and in the future would be rendered much weaker than their Ukrainian counterparts.
The signing of the new Minsk agreement, as well as Russian President Vladimir Putin’s direct participation in the negotiations, points to the Kremlin’s willingness to at least partially de-escalate the conflict at this time. The agreement includes some vague measures and conditions that all sides may ultimately chose not to implement. Several key points of contention remain unaddressed, and there are still many opportunities for the agreement to break down if they are not resolved. Therefore, political will, rather than the actual terms of the agreement, will determine whether a significant de-escalation is to take place.
end
Unbelievable!! did the USA blink on the potential to roll back sanctions on Russia?
what about the Crimea?
(courtesy zero hedge)
US Blinks: Kerry Says Prepared To Roll Back Sanctions On Russia
Did The US just blink? Perhaps under pressure from Merkel having enough of Obama’s “costs”, Secretary of State John Kerry just released the following statement…
John Kerry
The United States welcomes the news that the OSCE-led Trilateral Contact Group, supported by Chancellor Merkel and Presidents Hollande, Poroshenko, and Putin, reached agreement on a ceasefire and heavy weapons withdrawal in eastern Ukraine, and on the implementation of the September Minsk agreements. We particularly commend the diplomatic efforts of our European Allies, Chancellor Merkel and President Hollande, and their teams in making this agreement possible. Actions will be what matter now. The first test of this agreement and the prospects for a comprehensive settlement will be the full implementation of the ceasefire and the withdrawal of heavy weapons by all parties – by Ukraine, the separatists, and Russia. All the parties must show complete restraint in the run-up to the Sunday ceasefire, including an immediate halt to the Russian and separatist assault on Debaltseve and other Ukrainian towns.
The parties have a long road ahead before achieving peace and the full restoration of Ukraine’s sovereignty. The United States stands ready to assist in coordination with our European Allies and partners. We will judge the commitment of Russia and the separatists by their actions, not their words. As we have long said, the United States is prepared to consider rolling back sanctions on Russia when the Minsk agreements of September 2014, and now this agreement, are fully implemented. That includes a full ceasefire, the withdrawal of all foreign troops and equipment from Ukraine, the full restoration of Ukrainian control of the international border, and the release of all hostages.
We also welcome the news that the Government of Ukraine and the IMF have reached an agreement that will allow the IMF to provide Ukraine with $17.5 billion in financial assistance in support of economic reforms. This agreement will enable Ukraine to continue implementing the reforms it needs to build a stronger, more prosperous, democratic future for the people of Ukraine.
So Crimea, which was not mentioned, and whose “annexation” by Russia so infuriated the western leaders, is Vlad’s to keep
end
The following commentary from Graham Summers, summarizes in simple language the 9 trillion USA dollar short and what it means to the global finances:
(courtesy Graham Summers/Phoenix Research Capital)
The Problem Country That’s Bigger Than Greece, Spain Italy and France Combined
The financial world focuses far too much on stocks.
Today, the market is roaring higher… for no real reason. Nothing substantial has come out of the EU talks with Greece. And the world has much bigger problems to deal with than Greece.
The US Dollar carry trade is over $9 trillion in size.
This means that over $9 trillion has been borrowed (in US Dollars) and plunged into various asset classes and investment projects around the world.
Greece’s GDP is $241 billion in size. Even if you add in the economies Spain, Italy, AND France, the US DOLLAR CARRY TRADE IS LARGER.
Again, if the US carry trade was a single country it’d be bigger than Greece, Spain, Italy, AND France combined.
When you BORROW in US Dollars you are effectively SHORTING the US Dollar. So when the US Dollar rallies… you have to cover your SHORT or you blow up.
And the US Dollar is rallying… HARD.
This move took out an entire industry (oil shale). That was just the beginning. Anyone who has borrowed in US Dollars to finance an investment or project and didn’t hedge their currency risk is blowing up.
This is just the start of a multi-year bull market in the US Dollar. The US Dollar has broken out of a massive falling wedge pattern going back to the early ‘80s.
No one will be safe from this. Commodities, emerging markets, all of them are at risk of severe collapses in asset prices. We are talking about a financial trade that is larger than the economies of Spain, Italy, Greece and France combined… blowing up.
Just like 2008.
end
Last night after Raufeissen’s bonds collapsed due to huge amount of Swiss franc mortgages, the CEO goes on the air to complain about short sellers:
(courtesy zero hedge)
Austria’s 3rd Largest Bank Goes Full Bear Stearns: CEO Blames “Short Sellers” For Firm’s Demise
You know it’s bad when… you start blaming speculators. Very reminiscent of the “it’s not us, we have a solid balance sheet, it’s the short selling speculators” bullshit in the days before and after the stock crashes of American Insurance Group, Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers and Merrill Lynch; mere days after his bank’s bonds crashed, the CEO of Raiffeissen Bank (Austria’s 3rd largest) has stated (unequivocally) that“panic was created artificially,” blaming short-sellers for his bank’s demise.
RBI CEO Svelda tells DiePresse.com,
“This panic was created artificially to a certain degree.
25 percent of our free float was shorted. As some have speculated neatly on falling prices and our share beaten down properly.
And the whole thing because of an initial loss of 493 million euros?”
Yep all short-sellers…
Nothing to do with worries about Swiss Franc mortgages…As Bloomberg reports, Raiffeisen had a total of 4.3 billion euros of Swiss franc loans outstanding as of September 2014, according to estimates by Moody’s Investors Service.
The largest part of these are in Poland, where the franc has appreciated 17 percent against the zloty since Jan. 14, threatening to push up defaults on the bank’s 2.9 billion euros of mortgages in the Swiss currency.
“There’s a lot of people worried about the bank’s Swiss-franc mortgages in eastern Europe,” said Gregory Turnbull Schwartz, who helps oversee the equivalent of about $82 billion at Kames Capital in Edinburgh and doesn’t hold Raiffeisen bonds.
Raiffeisen said Jan. 15 that it can’t yet forecast the effects of the appreciation of the franc on its asset quality.
The bank “will certainly take one measure or the other in the near future,”Chief Executive Officer Karl Sevelda told reporters on the sidelines of the Euromoney CEE conference in Vienna today. He declined to elaborate. Franc loans in eastern Europe are “not a big problem,” he said.
And just forget about the fundamentals…
The plunge appears focused on the potential capital shortfalls and talk of the bank selling its Russian unit – both have been denied… (as Reuters reports),
Raiffeisen Bank International has no desire to exit the Russian market, Chief Executive Karl Sevelda told a newspaper in response to market rumours it could sell its lucrative Russian business.
The Austrian lender has “absolutely no intention to sell our Russian bank”, he told Der Standard in a report printed on Tuesday. A bank spokeswoman confirmed his remarks.
He was responding to Russian media reports that Raiffeisen was in talks with Alfa Bank about a potential sale. Sevelda dismissed these “unfounded rumours” and said Raiffeisen had “absolutely no contact” with Alfa Group.
Raiffeisen, which is conducting a strategic review of its portfolio, said this month losses for 2014 could surpass 500 million euros ($561.5 million) if it had to write down goodwill in Russia, its single most profitable market.
The spokeswoman also confirmed the paper’s report that Chief Financial Officer Martin Gruell had denied market talk Raiffeisen may need to raise capital. It raised about 2.8 billion euros a year ago via a rights issue.
* * *
Your more important currency crosses early Thursday morning:
Eur/USA 1.1342 up .0032 (with every country on earth buying euros to support it due to the Greek crisis)
USA/JAPAN YEN 119.76 down .444
GBP/USA 1.5349 up .0107
USA/CAN 1.2554 down .0064
This morning in Europe, the euro is up, trading now well above the 1.13 level at 1.1342 as Europe is supported by other nations keeping the Euro afloat, Europe reacts to deflation, announcements of massive stimulation, and the Greek crisis . In Japan Abe went all in with Abenomics with another round of QE purchasing 80 trillion yen from 70 trillion on Oct 31. The yen continues to trade in yoyo fashion as this morning it settled up again in Japan by 44 basis points and settling just below the 120 barrier to 119.76 yen to the dollar. The pound was up this morning as it now trades well above the 1.53 level at 1.5349.(very worried about the health of Barclays Bank and the FX/precious metals criminal investigation/Dec 12 a new separate criminal investigation on gold,silver oil manipulation). The Canadian dollar was up again and is trading at 1.2554 to the dollar. It seems that the 4 major global carry trades are being unwound. (1) The total dollar global short is 9 trillion USA, and as such we now witness a sea of red blood on the streets as derivatives blow up with the massive rise in the dollar against all paper currencies.We also have the second big yen carry trade unwind as the yen refuses to blow past the 120 level.(3) the Nikkei vs gold carry trade. (4) short Swiss Franc/long assets (European housing), the Nikkei, etc. These massive carry trades are terribly offside as they are being unwound. It is causing deflation as the world reacts to a lack of demand. Bourses around the globe are reacting in kind to these events as well as the potential for a GREXIT.
The NIKKEI: Thursday morning : closed
Trading from Europe and Asia:
1. Europe stocks all in the green
2/ Asian bourses mixed … Chinese bourses: Hang Sang in the green ,Shanghai in the green, Australia in the red: /Nikkei (Japan) green/India’s Sensex in the green/
Gold very early morning trading: $1223.00
silver:$16.85
Early Thursday morning USA 10 year bond yield: 2.04% !!! up 5 in basis points from Wednesday night/
USA dollar index early Thursday morning: 94.63 down 35 cents from Wednesday’s close.
This ends the early morning numbers.
And now for your closing numbers for Thursday:
Closing Portuguese 10 year bond yield: 2.47% down 10 in basis points from Wednesday
Closing Japanese 10 year bond yield: .40% !!! par in basis points from Wednesday and this is worth watching
Your closing Spanish 10 year government bond, Thursday down 3 in basis points in yield from Wednesday night.
Spanish 10 year bond yield: 1.62% !!!!!!
Your Thursday closing Italian 10 year bond yield: 1.65% down 5 in basis points from Wednesday:
trading 3 basis points higher than Spain.
IMPORTANT CURRENCY CLOSES FOR TODAY
Closing currency crosses for Thursday night/USA dollar index/USA 10 yr bond:
Euro/USA: 1.1412 up .0102
USA/Japan: 118.88 down 1.37
Great Britain/USA: 1.5244 down .0014
USA/Canada: 1.2484 d0wn .0135
The euro rose considerably this afternoon this news that Germany blinked with respect to the Greece crisis and the ceasefire in the Ukraine as it was up by 162 basis points finishing the day well above the 1.14 level to 1.1412. The yen was well up in the afternoon, and it was up by closing to the tune of 137 basis points and closing well below the 119 cross at 118.88 and finishing again below the key yen carry trade of 120. The British pound gained considerable ground during the afternoon session and was up on the day closing at 1.5404. The Canadian dollar was up again today due to the higher oil price. It closed at 1.2484 to the USA dollar
As explained above, the short dollar carry trade is being unwound, the yen carry trade , the Nikkei/gold carry trade, and finally the long dollar/short Swiss franc carry trade are all being unwound and these reversals are causing massive derivative losses. And as such these massive derivative losses is the powder keg that will destroy the entire financial system. The losses on the oil front will no doubt produce many dead bodies. The last asset still rising are the stock exchanges.
Your closing 10 yr USA bond yield: 1.98 down 1 in basis points from Wednesday
Your closing USA dollar index: 94.11 down 87 cents on the day.
European and Dow Jones stock index closes:
England FTSE up 9.94 points or 0.15%
Paris CAC up 46.82 or 1.00%
German Dax up 167.54 or 1.56%
Spain’s Ibex up 197.40 or 1.90%
Italian FTSE-MIB up 437.15 or 2.13%
The Dow: up 110.24 or 0.62%
Nasdaq; up 54.61 or 1.14%
OIL: WTI 51.20 !!!!!!!
Brent: 56.15!!!!
Closing USA/Russian rouble cross: 65.02 up 1/8 rouble per dollar on the day.
And now for your more important USA economic stories for today:
Your New York trading for today:
VIXnado Sends Stocks Near Record Highs, Dollar Slammed
Worst back-to-back retail sales since the financial crisis explodes the narrative that low gas prices are a stimulus, a truce in Ukraine (which we already had and by the way the Hyrvnia imploded to fresh record lows today – not exactly signaling exuberance), some chatter of compromise in Europe (though we’ve heard that before)… which leaves VIX… which was monkey-hammered to ensure record highs prove (despite a total collapse in macro and earnings fundamentals) everything is awesome and confidence is maintained…
Stocks went up… a lot…
VIX went down… a lot… lowest close since 12/26/14… at 15.3
AAPL went up… again…
From the “CNBC Greek Deal” rumor highs last night, we dumped on the denials then soared all day… after Ukraine news (with a slight pause for the shittiest retail sales datas in 6 years)
On the week – everything is awesome…
Away from that tom-foolery – FX and credit markets turmoiled quite significantly…
Treasury yields spiked higher on “truce” news, the collapsed on the dismal retail sales data only to bounce higher after a tiny tail in the 30Y auction… before yields fell (bonds rallied) into the close – Treasuries rallied
Umm yeah!
The USDollar lost significantly today as JPY strengthened (BoJ sounding a little hawkish) and EUR strength (Ukraine? and maybe Greece) – but everything rallied against the USD.
Despite the USD weakness, gold and silver flatlined as copper and crude surged…
With another epic pump-and-dump early on in WTI…
About that oil and stocks are not correlated bullshit…
Energy stocks rose to valuation levels not seen since the peak of the dot-com bubble…
If the rally was predicated on a Ukraine “truce” deal, why did the Hyrvnia collapse even further?
So let’s take a look at Stocks, Bonds, The USDollar, and VIX over the day’s events…
Charts: Bloomberg
end
Retail sales which is 70% of USA GDP plunges again and worse than expected. This is the second month in a row of poor retail sales numbers and yet the Dow continues to rocket northbound;
(courtesy zero hedge)
Retail Sales Plunge Twice As Much As Expected. Worst Back-To-Back Drop Since Oct 2009
Following last month’s narrative-crushing drop in retail sales, despite all that low interest rate low gas price stimulus, January was more of the same as hopeful expectations for a modest rebound were denied. Falling 0.8% (against a 0.9% drop in Dec), missing expectations of -0.4%, this is the worst back-to-back drop in retail sales since Oct 2009. Retail sales declined in 6 of the 13 categories.
Retail sales disappoint… again…
In worse back-to-back drop since oct 09…
Full Breakdown…
Charts: Bloomberg
end
Jobless claims are now above 300,000 as the shale state losses mount.
(courtesy zero hedge/BLS)
Jobless Claims Jump Back Above 300k As Shale State Losses Mount
As the noise of jobless claims data once again ripples through the narrative of unequivocally good low gas prices, initial claims in Shale States continues to trend higher. TX and PA saw the largest rise in claims (from the Shale States) lagged a week. Overall, initial jobless claims jujmped 24k to 304k (above the supposed Maginot Line demarcating the “everything is awesome” from the “we’re gonna need a bigger QE”) missing expectations by the most in a month.
Initial Claims trend appears to have seen a regime shift…
as Shale States continue to see a trend higher in jobless claims… (4-week average used to smooth noise)
Charts: Bloomberg
end
This is big news. We pointed this out to you last week. It seems we are heading for a catastrophic shutdown of West Coast Ports due to the striking action of the Longshoremen. This will have a devastating effect on the GDP of the USA .
The “Catastrophic Shutdown Of America’s Supply Chain” Begins: Stunning Photos Of West Coast Port Congestion
One week ago, when previewing what may be the first lockout of the West Coast Ports since 2002, we cited the Retail Industry Leaders Association who, realizing that failure to reach an agreement between the dockworker union and their bosses, the Pacific Maritime Association representing port management would lead to devastating consequences for the US retail industry, had several very damning soundbites:
- “a work slowdown during contract negotiations over the past seven months has already created logistic nightmares for American exporters, manufacturers and retailers dependent on an efficient supply chain. A complete shutdown would be catastrophic, with hundreds of thousands of jobs at risk if America’s supply chain grinds to a halt.“
- “A west coast port shutdown would be an economic disaster.”
- “A shutdown would not only impact the hundreds of thousands of jobs working directly in America’s transportation supply chain, but the reality is the entire economy would be impacted as exports sit on docks and imports sit in the harbor waiting for manufacturers to build products and retailers to stock shelves.”
And the punchline: “The slowdown is already making life difficult, but a shutdown could derail the economy completely.”
Just so readers have a sense of what is at stake, this is what the average dockworker makes: $147,000 a year in salary, plus $35,000 a year in employer-paid health care and an annual pension of $80,000 (according to an association press release). It is the overtime compensation to the total shown here, which grosses to over a quarter of a million dollars, that dockworkers are negotiating to raise or else the key US supply-chains gets it.
Incidentally, the demands of the dockworker union and their leverage is precisely the reason for the dramatic discrepancy we showed in the following chart:
In any case, as of last night, the choking of the US supply-chain has officially begin, when as the LA Times reported last night, “West Coast ports — including the nation’s busiest in Los Angeles and Long Beach — will partially shut down for four days as shipping companies plan to dramatically slash dock work amid an increasingly contentious labor dispute.”
More:
Terminal operators and shipping lines said that they would stop the unloading of ships Thursday, Saturday, Sunday and Monday, because they don’t want to pay overtime to workers who, they allege, have deliberately slowed operations to the point of causing a massive bottleneck. Thursday is Lincoln’s Birthday and Monday is Presidents Day, which are holidays for the workers.
Slowing down work “amounts to a strike with pay, and we will reduce the extent to which we pay premium rates for such a strike,” said Wade Gates, spokesman for the Pacific Maritime Assn., the employer group representing the shipping companies. The local union in Los Angeles and Long Beach has denied using slowdown tactics.
Accoring to the LA Times, it is not clear if the partial shutdown foreshadows a total closure of the ports. Fears of a lockout of dockworkers, who have been without a contract since July, have risen in the last week and the two sides haven’t held talks since Friday. SF Gate was far more clear on what the dockworker action means: “West Coast ports to shut down 4 days amid labor dispute.”
Work delays and stoppages over the past three months have caused mounting problems for Bay Area importers and small-business owners, who say they are losing money as trucks line up daily outside the Port of Oakland waiting for container ships anchored in San Francisco Bay to unload.
The shutting down of port operations is ironic because it’ll make the situation worse, said union officials who claimed the association canceled a negotiating session Wednesday and has not been available since last Friday.
“This is an effort by the employers to put economic pressure on our members and to gain leverage in contract talks,” said Robert McEllrath, president of the longshore and warehouse union. “The union is standing by ready to negotiate, as we have been for the past several days.”
Regardless of who is at fault for the (partial) shut down, one can’t blame dockworkers for doing what Greece is actively doing at the same time in its own negotiations with Europe: maximizing its leverage. Because as Bank of America showed yesterday, in a piece dedicated precisely to this topic, nothing short of 3.5% of marginal US GDP is at steak, which translated into CAGR terms, means that the fate of America’s estimated 3% growth in 2015 is suddenly in the hands of a few thousand port workers, and with that, whether or not the US has a recession.
Some more thoughts from BofA:
Could port activity grind to a halt?
Due to continued unsuccessful contract negotiations between West Coast port employers (Pacific Maritime Association) and workers (International Longshore and Warehouse Union), there is a growing risk of a shutdown/lockout at West Coast docks, possibly within days. This past weekend, ports temporarily halted operations, adding to uncertainty. In our view, although a port strike/lockout could weigh on operations and profitability in some industries, the economic fallout of a one-week strike is likely to be limited to a loss of $0.8-1.8bn, representing a 0.1-0.2% hit to annualized GDP growth in 1Q15.
Size matters
Since the fall, a notable disruption in activity at the ports has materialized, and the risk is the current delays could spiral into full-blown gridlock, or that employers could lock out workers. West Coast ports are an important component of US trade. As cited by our Transportation Analyst Ken Hoexter, the value of total traffic at West Coast ports (waterborne, air and land) accounts for 12% of GDP. However, drilling down specifically to goods arriving/departing by water vessels (and hence, impacted by the labor dispute) reveals a much smaller share, only 3.5% of GDP or roughly $600bn, as of 2014.
Gauging the economy-wide risk during a shutdown
The economic fallout of a port shutdown is challenging to measure and depends heavily on the technique of analysis. Economic impact studies of West Coast port shutdowns have yielded loss estimates as high as $2bn per day. However, analysis by Peter Hall of the University of Waterloo and by the US Congressional Budget Office criticized such techniques as they fail to account for the ability for firms to substitute to alternative transportation routes, resulting in inflated loss estimates. Instead, according to research published by the CBO in 2006, the fallout is likely much lower, roughly $65mn to $150mn per day if Los Angeles and Long Beach ports were to shut down for a week in 2004. To get a sense of what the risks are in today, we gross that figure up to account for higher trade volumes, and include all West Coast ports. Our back of the envelope calculation suggests the daily loss to GDP would be $150-350mn per day, or $0.8-1.8bn per week. That would represent 0.1-0.2% hit to annualized 1Q15 GDP growth.
Learning from the past: short-term pain is likely
If history is any guide, a temporary port shutdown would acutely hurt the trade sector in the short term, but would not threaten to derail the recovery. In 2002, port workers at 29 West Coast ports were locked out for roughly 10 days in October, before President Bush invoked the Taft-Hartley Act to reopen the ports.
What could go wrong?
We highlight two key scenarios that may lead to greater downside risk relative to our base case:
- A protracted disruption could trigger non-linear (accelerating) economic costs as temporary contingency measures run their course, resulting in worsening supply chain disruptions. President Obama could intervene by invoking the Taft-Hartley Act as was done in 2002, but it is not clear if or how quickly the White House would be willing to step into a labor dispute this time around.
There is uncertainty regarding the capacity of alternative transportation routes. Extensive use of air freight and Canadian/Eastern ports may lead to capacity constraints at those sites, limiting the ability of industry to successfully substitute to alternative supply chains for an extended period.
So the bottom line is that nobody really knows what will happen if the “partial” stoppage becomes a permanent one, as dockworkers try lever their influence on the US economy (which according to financial comedy TV is so strong, it should have no problem to meet their demands, right?), but it is safe to say that the final outcome will be somewhere between the “catastrophic” devastation for the economy which the retail industry predicts, and anywhere up to a 3.5% hit to the GDP, which in turn means an economic recession, if only temporary.
One thing, however, about which there is no doubt at all, is the unprecedented congestion that has slammed the Port of Los Angeles and Long Beach harbor: that is very much real, as can be seen on the series of photos below courtesy of Mike Kelley. From his blog:
As anyone who follows my work knows, I’m fascinated by industry and infrastructure. For the past few weeks, a labor dispute has been unfolding at the Port of Los Angeles and the Port of Long Beach. After flying over the area while coming in to land at LAX, I saw all of these giant container ships anchored offshore and instantly knew that I had to photograph it.
The next day I called my pilot and said ‘when is the soonest we can go up?!’ Less than 24 hours later we were in the air. It was one of the most exciting experiences I’ve had doing aerial photography – being that far out at sea, with the huge swells underneath you, and these massive, massive container ships everywhere was like living a scene out of Walter Mitty’s life.
Here are pictures showing the huge backlog of cargoes heading into LA, SF and other major western ports:
Cargo ships have been backed up for weeks on end at the ports of LA and Long Beach amid a labor dispute.
The size of these ships blows the mind; many of them are over a thousand feet long.
We photographed them from anywhere between 200 and 5,500 feet, and even at this height the enormous size was something else entirely.
The haze and setting sun created an ethereal mood to all of the pictures
Cargoes from around the world are backed up right now
I’ve never seen ANYTHING like this, even rush hour at the 405 doesn’t look so bad.
Colorful and massive, this ship is over 1000 feet from end to end.
From this angle, the scale and size of the city and ships becomes quickly apparent
* * *
Finally keep in mind that to many economists, or at least those who realize that the US economy is in a far worse shape than what official government data represents, an “exogenous” event like a West Coast port strike, just like a “Polar Vortex” is precisely what the doctor ordered. After all, what better scapegoat for the lack of growth than a few thousand dockworkers who are merely leveraging capitalism as much as they can… even if it means shutting down key US economic supply-chains in the process.
end
The following is an amazing chart. It shows the and S and P earnings falling as a percentage each year together with falling sales. The stock market and its resultant P/E just does not make sense as earnings are not increasing
(courtesy zero hedge)
Chart Of The Day: “Profits And Sales Are Crumbling”
When not even Tesla’s non-GAAP adjustment magic, shown previously in the following “bridge“, can boost sales or earnings any more to beat Wall Street expectations, one things is clear: as SocGen’s Albert Edwards puts it “US corporate profits and sales are crumbling.”
It’s not just his opinion: it’s the truth, presented visually:
“And for those who dismiss this profits slump as just driven by the energy sector, take a look at the table below right, where US tech, telcos, consumer discretionary and staples are all seeing sharp EPS slowdowns. The strong dollar is hurting.”
Meanwhile, the S&P is under 1% from its all time high.
We will see you on Friday.
bye for now
Harvey,
[…] READ MORE […]
LikeLike